Natalie auditioned in Washington, D.C., where she sang "In My Blood" by Shawn Mendes. All three judges voted "Yes", sending her to the next round. Her audition was not televised.
Hollywood Round Edit
Natalie sang "Who's Loving You" by the Jackson 5 for the Genre Challenge. The performance was not aired, but she made it to Duets Round. Natalie was shown in the second part of Hollywood Week, in a duet called "Major and Minor" with Marcus Tinsley singing "It's a Man's Man's Man's World" by James Brown. Both contestants advanced to the next round. Natalie performed "Always Remember Us This Way", from A Star Is Born, during the Solo Round. This performance was not aired, but she advanced to Showcase Round.
Hawaii Round Edit
Although not televised, Natalie sang "Cool" by The Jonas Brothers. Afterwards, the judges told her during her untelevised Final Judgment that she did not become a Top 20 finalist.
|Round||Song Choice||Original Artist||Theme (if any)||Result|
|Auditions||"In My Blood"||Shawn Mendes||None||Advanced|
|Hollywood Week||"Who's Loving You"||Jackson 5||Hollywood Round 1||Safe|
|Hollywood Week||"It's a Man's Man's Man's World"||James Brown||Hollywood Round 2||Safe|
|Hollywood Week||"Always Remember Us This Way"||Lady Gaga||Hollywood Round 3||Safe|
|Hawaii Round||"Cool"||Jonas Brothers||Showcase Round||Eliminated|