Josh auditioned in Chicago. He sang "Back at One" by Brian McKnight. All four judges voted "yes", sending him to the next round.
Josh's stay in Hollywood wasn't shown much, but he did manage to make the Top 28 Guys. However, the judges told him he needed to participate in a sing-off with Adam Sanders to determine whether he would advance to the Top 20 Guys. He sang "Georgia on My Mind" by Ray Charles. Afterwards, the judges told him he did enough to land the final spot in the Top 20 Guys.
Josh appeared in Male Group 2 and sang an original song called "I'm Better With You". Afterwards, the judges told him he did not become a semifinalist.
|Candice Glover · Kree Harrison · Angie Miller · Amber Holcomb · Janelle Arthur · Lazaro Arbos · Burnell Taylor · Devin Velez · Paul Jolley · Curtis Finch, Jr.|
|Charlie Askew · Nick Boddington · Aubrey Cleland · Zoanette Johnson · Adriana Latonio · Elijah Liu · Vincent Powell · Cortez Shaw · Breanna Steer · Tenna Torres|
|Melinda Ademi · Juliana Chahayed · Cristabel Clack · JDA · Rachel Hale · Kevin Harris · Jett Hermano · Josh Holiday · Brandy Hotard · Isabelle · Johnny Keyser · Kamaria Ousley · Gurpreet Singh Sarin · Jimmy Smith · Bryant Tadeo · Mathenee Treco · Shubha Vedula · Chris Watson · David Oliver Willis · Jenny Beth Willis|