Johnny Hayes was a contestant on Season 4 of American Idol. Audition[edit | edit source] Johnny auditioned in St. Louis. He sang "My First Love" by Rene and Angela. He was eliminated at this point of the competition. Retrieved from "https://americanidol.fandom.com/wiki/Johnny_Hayes?oldid=27574" Categories: Contestants Season 4 contestants Add category Cancel Save Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.