American Idol Wiki

John "J.P." Molfetta was a contestant on Season 4 of American Idol.


J.P. auditioned in New Orleans with his twin brother Rich. They sang "I'll Make Love to You" by Boyz II Men. Although Randy and Paula voted "yes", Gene, and Simon voted "no", eliminating him from the competition.

J.P. auditioned alone in San Francisco. He sang "Never Keeping Secrets" by Babyface. Although Brandy and Paula voted "yes", Randy and Simon voted "no", eliminating him from the competition again.


  • J.P.'s second audition made him the final televised contestant of Season 4.
  • During both auditions, Paula voted "yes" and Simon voted "no" each time.