Colton's audition was not televised, but a flashback revealed that he auditioned in Charleston. He sang "I Believe I Can Fly" by R. Kelly. It's unknown how the judges voted, but at least two of them voted "yes," sending him to the next round.
Colton was shown on the second day of Hollywood Week singing "Everything I Do (I Do it For You)" by Bryan Adams. During his final performance, he sang "Can You Feel the Love Tonight" by Elton John. He managed to make the judges' final fifty. It was revealed during the final deliberation that he had made the Top 24 instead of Kyle Ensley.
Colton sang "Suspicious Minds" by Elvis Presley. He was placed in the Bottom 2 for that week, eliminating him from the competition.
|David Cook · David Archuleta · Syesha Mercado · Jason Castro · Brooke White · Carly Smithson · Kristy Lee Cook · Michael Johns · Ramiele Malubay · Chikezie · Amanda Overmyer · David Hernandez|
|Danny Noriega · Asia'h Epperson · Luke Menard · Kady Malloy · Robbie Carrico · Alaina Whitaker · Alexandréa Lushington · Jason Yeager · Colton Berry · Joanne Borgella · Amy Davis · Garrett Haley|