Casey was shown in the same Group of Eight as Maddy Curtis. He sang "I Don't Need No Doctor" by Ray Charles. He did enough to advance. He was later shown in a group with called "Middle C" with Janell Wheeler and Jermaine Purifoy singing "Closer" by Ne-Yo. Every member of his group advanced. On the final day in Hollywood Week, he sang "Bubbly" by Colbie Caillat. After the judges' verdict, he was placed in the same holding room as Tim Urban, Tyler Grady, Andrew Garcia, Todrick Hall, Katie Stevens, Jermaine Sellers, Siobhan Magnus, Crystal Bowersox, Alex Lambert, Michael Lynche, Thaddeus Johnson, Tori Kelly, Lilly Scott and Jeff Goldford. Everyone in his room advanced. At the final deliberation, it was revealed that he did enough to make the Top 24.
Casey sang "Heaven" by Bryan Adams. He received enough votes to be considered "safe" for that week.
Casey sang "I Don't Want to Be" by Gavin DeGraw. He received enough votes to be considered "safe" for that week.
Casey sang "You'll Think of Me" by Keith Urban. He received enough votes to become a Top 12 finalist.
Casey sang "It's All Over Now" by The Valentinos.
- He notably took off his shirt during his audition, much to the excitement of Kara and Victoria.
|Lee DeWyze · Crystal Bowersox · Casey James · Michael Lynche · Aaron Kelly · Siobhan Magnus · Tim Urban · Katie Stevens · Andrew Garcia · Didi Benami · Paige Miles · Lacey Brown|
|Lilly Scott · Alex Lambert · Todrick Hall · Katelyn Epperly · Haeley Vaughn · Michelle Delamor · Jermaine Sellers · John Park · Tyler Grady · Ashley Rodriguez · Joe Munoz · Janell Wheeler|